What makes a good Oreo cookie? The cookie can't be too "crumby," the taste of both the cookie and the cream must be well-balanced without either one overpowering the other, it can't be too sweet, too rich, too creamy, or too dry...does it sound like I'm being overly picky? Does it seem like too much to hope for in a cookie that has been long loved for its simplicity, hailed as "milk's favorite cookie?"
Actually, it isn't. The Oreo company managed to create such a cookie that fit all of the above criteria and still managed to retain its simplicity. It was the Marshmallow Crispy Oreo cookie. It was fantastic, and especially comparing it to two other Oreo flavors really put it into perspective. The packaging was flawless and the taste was excellent--the only thing lacking in this cookie was its ability to hold itself together as I bit down on it. Still, it didn't bother me much because, I mean, all cookies leave crumbs and fall apart eventually.
Presentation/Packaging: Perfectly packaged with an appetizing picture of a giant Oreo cookie dipped in snow-white milk, the presentation of the Oreo cookie is fantastic.
Actually, it isn't. The Oreo company managed to create such a cookie that fit all of the above criteria and still managed to retain its simplicity. It was the Marshmallow Crispy Oreo cookie. It was fantastic, and especially comparing it to two other Oreo flavors really put it into perspective. The packaging was flawless and the taste was excellent--the only thing lacking in this cookie was its ability to hold itself together as I bit down on it. Still, it didn't bother me much because, I mean, all cookies leave crumbs and fall apart eventually.
Presentation/Packaging: Perfectly packaged with an appetizing picture of a giant Oreo cookie dipped in snow-white milk, the presentation of the Oreo cookie is fantastic.
Texture/Firmness: The moment I take the cookie from the perfectly packaged box, it breaks in half. Each time I bite into the cookie, it keeps breaking apart in my fingers until I am holding a mess of crumbs in one hand. It’s too fragile, too “crumby,” and falls apart easily. But then again, pretty much all cookies do that.
As for the taste, each flavor had its own unique sensation.
The Good:
Marshmallow Crispy - The creamy marshmallow sandwiched in-between the two cookie pieces is the perfect balance between the sweet, frosting-like taste and the vanilla flavored cookies. They complement each other perfectly, neither overpowering or being overpowered by the other.
Stars: 3/4The Bad:
Lemon - The sweetness of the lemon cream explodes in your mouth the minute you bite into the cookie. However, it’s overly sweet and rich--almost like syrup or medicine, leaving you with a queasy feeling in your stomach. It reminded me of kids' toothpaste, the sweet, fruity kind that parents buy kids who protest that the paste is too minty. The sweet, syrupy taste of the lemon cream overpowers the taste of the cracker--in comparison, the cracker is tasteless and bland.
Stars: 1/4
Berry Burst Ice Cream - Even the name is misleading. Ice cream--who doesn't like ice cream? Just thinking about it is appetizing. Even sweeter than the lemon Oreo, this cookie is also dominated by the syrupy, overpowering taste of berry. You can’t taste the cookie, and about halfway through, your mouth and stomach tell you you’ve had enough--you want to stop, feeling queasy.
Stars: 1/4
I had such a nice moment with my Marshmallow Crispy Oreo, I was actually eager to try the other ones, hoping they'd be just as good. I almost groaned in disappointment as soon as I bit into them--like a second movie sequel that just isn't as good as the original, these other two flavors were a complete let-down. Sometimes it really is best to keep things simple. The Marshmallow Crispy Oreo won three stars in that it successfully balanced out the taste of the sweet marshmallow cream with the vanilla flavored cookie with just the right amount of sweetness and just the right degree of hardness in the cookie.
Stars: 1/4
I had such a nice moment with my Marshmallow Crispy Oreo, I was actually eager to try the other ones, hoping they'd be just as good. I almost groaned in disappointment as soon as I bit into them--like a second movie sequel that just isn't as good as the original, these other two flavors were a complete let-down. Sometimes it really is best to keep things simple. The Marshmallow Crispy Oreo won three stars in that it successfully balanced out the taste of the sweet marshmallow cream with the vanilla flavored cookie with just the right amount of sweetness and just the right degree of hardness in the cookie.